The evaluation link for the NEH is here.
Does this link work better?
So you fill in your first and last name with email (FYI, it doesn't seem important what email you use. I just tried it with my gmail as opposed to my school email and it worked). So, those blanks are filled in. Proceed down the page and hit the "select" button next to the NITS. This should get you to the page with the eval questions.
Did this link work for anyone besides me? Anyone have some light to shed? Help!